If you use Google Chrome, you may have found that several months ago when they added their built-in PDF viewer that PDFs would download without a format attached if you disabled this viewer. This was a real pain in the butt for me, as I use Skim (which is far superior to the in-browser PDF viewer) to read papers.
I had been pleading, unsuccessfully, for Google to fix this issue, as well as many other scientists who use ArXiv daily. The latest post in the thread by Zhiyu Zhang brought up the fact that if you use the German mirror de.arxiv.org, the PDF files are properly tagged again.
This led me to make a change to Vox Charta’s ArXiv links, which now automatically point to de.arxiv.org if it detects the user is using Chrome. Also, I found that through ADS’ preferences that you can change your ArXiv mirror preference to the German mirror, ensuring that all ArXiv links point to this mirror. These changes completely solve the problem for me.
Update: I later learned that the APS mirror also handles PDFs correctly. This is probably a better option for those residing in the United States.